Retsy Series 1 · Card 0518 · 90-TOY

Eyeball Soup Slime

Mmm, chunky.

Green slime sold in a tiny soup can, packed with floating rubber eyeballs that stared right back at you.

Card no.: 0518 of 1,280
Set: 90s Toys & Games · 90-TOY
Year: 1995
Type: Novelty slime with rubber eyeballs
Found at: Toy store impulse bin
Cost back then: $2.49

Rip a pack Find it in the checklist

Nostalgia9/10

Hype8/10

Weirdness10/10

Trade value5/10

The story · 1995

The story of Eyeball Soup Slime

Peel back the lid and Eyeball Soup Slime stared right at you. Kids fished out the rubber eyeballs, stuck them on their foreheads and chased siblings around the kitchen. It left a faint green stain on everything it touched, especially the couch. Moms hid the can in the garage, and kids always found it.

Fun fact

Every can promised twelve eyeballs, but counting them always came out to eleven, or occasionally fourteen.

Six finishes

187 copies of Eyeball Soup Slime exist

Eyeball Soup Slime comes in six finishes: 100 Base, 50 Holo, 25 Laser and 10 Gold copies, plus one Super Laser and one Misprint that exist exactly once. Every copy is minted to the wallet that rips it, with its own serial number.

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Base finish — **Base**100 copies · Common

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Holo finish — **Holo**50 copies · Uncommon

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Laser finish — **Laser**25 copies · Rare

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Gold finish — **Gold**10 copies · Very rare

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Super Laser finish — **Super Laser**1 copy · 1 of 1

Eyeball Soup Slime, Retsy card 0518 in the Misprint finish — **Misprint**1 copy · 1 of 1

90-TOY

More from 90s Toys & Games

Eyeball Soup Slime is one of 32 cards in the 90s Toys & Games set. Here are the other 31.